CSS Academy
← CSS 2024 English Essay Paper

English Essay · CSS 2024 · Question 9

Globalization and National Economics

By CSP Qasim Farooq

Understanding the topic

The topic names two things and leaves the relationship to you. Use that freedom deliberately. The most defensible frame: globalisation has not abolished national economic policy, it has changed what policy can and cannot do.

Give the argument a spine with the policy trilemma: no country can have free capital movement, a fixed exchange rate and independent monetary policy all at once. Then bring the essay up to date. Supply chains are being redrawn, rich countries are doing industrial policy again, and trade restrictions are now justified on security grounds. Being able to say the direction of travel changed around 2016 marks the essay as current rather than a rerun of 1990s debates.

Outline

  1. Introduction. Thesis: globalisation constrains and redirects national economic policy rather than abolishing it, and the constraint is now loosening in a specific direction.
  2. What globalisation did
    • Trade liberalisation, capital mobility, and cross-border production networks
    • Poverty reduction and convergence in participating economies
    • Distributional consequences within countries, often obscured by aggregate gains
  3. The constraint on national policy
    • The trilemma: capital mobility, exchange rate stability, and monetary autonomy
    • Tax competition and the limits on corporate taxation
    • Regulatory harmonisation pressures and standard-setting by the largest markets
  4. What national policy still determines
    • Human capital, infrastructure, and institutional quality
    • Sectoral positioning within global value chains
    • Social protection systems that mediate distributional effects domestically
    • Evidence that policy divergence persists among similarly exposed economies
  5. The current reconfiguration
    • Supply chain resilience and friend-shoring after recent disruptions
    • The return of explicit industrial policy in advanced economies
    • Trade measures justified on national security grounds
    • Slowing growth in trade as a share of global output
  6. Implications for developing economies
    • Narrowing of the export-led development path used by earlier entrants
    • Opportunity in supply chain relocation for states positioned to receive it
    • Increased exposure to external financial conditions
  7. Pakistan's position
    • Low integration into value chains relative to regional comparators
    • Export concentration and its vulnerability
    • Regional trade as an underused route
  8. Conclusion. Globalisation altered the terms on which national economic policy operates; it never removed the responsibility.

Sample introduction

No national economy can completely isolate itself from the world, but neither can it afford to become helplessly dependent upon it. Globalization has connected economies through trade, finance, technology, migration, investment, and global supply chains, allowing countries to access larger markets, attract capital, acquire knowledge, and specialise in areas of comparative advantage. For developing states, such integration can accelerate growth, create employment, and expose domestic industries to new technologies and competitive standards. However, excessive dependence on imported energy, food, technology, external borrowing, or a narrow range of export markets can leave national economies dangerously exposed to wars, financial crises, pandemics, commodity shocks, and disruptions in international supply chains. Global competition can also weaken uncompetitive domestic industries and widen inequality when the benefits of integration remain concentrated among a small segment of society. The objective should therefore be neither economic nationalism that rejects global markets nor unrestricted globalization that sacrifices domestic resilience. Thus, successful national economics in a globalized world requires strategic openness: engaging international markets for growth while developing sufficient domestic productive capacity, diversification, and economic resilience to protect the national interest when global conditions deteriorate.

Continue your English Essay preparation